Episode: 2 (The Velvet Web)
Doctor: William Hartnell
Companions: Barbara, Ian, and Susan
Writer: Terry Nation
Director: John Gorrie
Producer: Verity Lambert
Original Air Date: 18/04/1964
THERE’S NO SUCH THING AS A FREE LUNCH (and other stories)
In which hemlines are high, baddies are boogly-eyed, Marxist subtext abounds, and everyone is hypnotised but Barbara...who then inadvertently plunges an entire civilisation into utter screaming chaos.
BUT LET US WASTE NO MORE TIME SHILLY-SHALLYING for Babs is missing presumed mauled and Ian is getting antsy. The Doctor reckons she’s probably behind this triangulated wall, so of course Ian immediately springs into action; the Doctor tells Ian not to be precipitous; Ian forces the doors open anyway.
Ian sets his Mood Organ to 'OMG WHERE'S BARBARA!?' |
Then HOLY RETINAS BATMAN there’s a blinding flash of light and the three of them find themselves in some sort of Greco-Roman leisure palace. Ian can hardly believe his eyes, for there on a chaise-longue resplendent in a Greco-Roman Dress of Floaty Loveliness is none other than Bae; I’m going to say he’s probably dreamed about this sort of thing. Susan runs over and hugs her, and Babs explains that falling through space freaked her out a bit so she tried to tear the travel dial of her wrist, hence the blood on it.
Colour set feat. Weeping Angel containment units |
Ian instantly enters into the spirit of the Very Weird Situation and he and Babs start roleplaying or something. Babs seems to have no problem ordering the extras about, and tells them to get some food for her friends. The Doctor pronounces the place ‘sensuous and decadent, but rather pleasant’. Which sounds like something you’d find written on Mary Poppins’s magical tape-measure. Then he finds a pomegranate. DON’T EAT IT, DOCTOR! HAVE YOU NEVER HEARD OF PERSEPHONE?
Susan enjoys her teachers' weird power play flirting; the Doctor not so much. |
The rest of the food arrives, and Ian is justifiably wary:
BARBARA: What's the matter, don't you like it?You can tell this is Terry Nation, actually, because Ian’s characterisation here is similar to the way he was written in The Daleks: cynical, slightly to the left, and unwilling to take advantage of the altruism of strangers. The Doctor, meanwhile, gives zero fucks and continues to be enthusiastic to the point of zeal about food.
IAN: No, I've just realised nobody's shown me the menu. [. . .] See, I don't know the price yet.
BARBARA: But we're guests here!
IAN: Oh, you've met the host, have you?
Enter a man in a very long cloak; Ian reckons ‘this is where we pay the bill’; Babs tells him to wind his neck in. And HOLY HEMLINES BATMAN the man’s tunic is short to the point of indecency.
Man in the High Tassles |
He’s also brought some exposition with him, after Babs responds to being asked whether there’s anything she wants by requesting KNOWLEDGE. Bullet-point time again:
- This place is the city of Morphoton.
- Its people are perhaps the most contented in the universe.
- Nothing the people desire is denied them.
So then of course Susan – Susan the homesick spacechild, Susan the wanderer, Susan who wants to know all the mysteries of the stars, Susan who has just found herself in the city equivalent of the Mirror of Erised – ASKS THE NICE MAN FOR A DRESS.
FUCKSAKE, TERRY. FIRST BARBARA GETS THE ROMANTIC GIFT OF DRESSMAKING FABRIC FROM HER THAL WOULD-BE LOVER ON SKARO AND NOW SUSAN GETS A SILK GOWN AS THE THING SHE DESIRES MOST.
The Doctor is sternly mortified at Susan’s presumption, but the Man in the High Tassles tells him it’s no bother. Then this happens:
MAN: And you? Have you no wish, no great desire?Yes, grandfather, what is it? A brain? A heart? A home? The nerve? A working time machine perhaps?
DOCTOR: Well er, yes, perhaps, but er... I'm afraid it's not quite as easy as giving Susan a dress out of that.
SUSAN: What is it grandfather?
DOCTOR: Well perhaps, um, if I had to choose, a well-equipped laboratory with every conceivable instrument. Yes, yes!Hmm. Well, I suppose a dream laboratory is pretty good.
MAN: It will be arranged.
Anyway, the leggy dude wishes them all good night, and Susan is dead on her feet; Babs levers her over to bed, speculating that the excitement has probably been too much for her, like she’s a fucking five-year-old. Poor Susan. Bad Terry.
The sun has gone to bed and so must I |
But also Good Terry, because now Barbara and Ian are having another Excellent Barbara and Ian Conversation like they did on Skaro:
BARBARA: Well you don't look very happy.Maybe that's because all the statues are actually Weeping Angels. Wouldn't that be a twist? Ahem. Sorry. Anyway, Ian asks Babs if he's being ridiculous, and though she doesn't exactly pull her punches when she answers in the affirmative and tells him to sleep on it, it's still a bit gorgeous. I love Ian’s little Marxist moments when they crop up, and it’s interesting that Barbara is starting up a debate about whether or not you can apply Earth standards to other planets. They do complement one another very well: Ian doesn’t trust the 1% but also doesn’t trust aliens because they look alien; Babs has no qualms about taking whatever she can get but is entirely willing to put anything that seems a bit off down to cultural differences and accommodate it. Also what is personal space. Also also, Ian appears to have a DH Lawrence phoenix on the back of his jacket, which would explain the UST.
IAN: Me? No no no, not at all. I think it's all marvellous.
BARBARA: Not very convincing. I don't know what you want.
IAN: Perhaps it's my materialistic side. How rich and powerful do you have to be to give things away free?
BARBARA: Oh, now don't spoil it all for me!
IAN: (Laughs.) I didn't mean to do that.
BARBARA: You can't apply Earth standards, you just can't!
IAN: (Quietly.) No. It's certainly very different here. You noticed that man's eyes?
BARBARA: Well, what about them?
IAN: He didn't blink once.
Do or do not. There is no try. |
Anyway, they all lie down on their couches, and then HOLY GREEN MAN BATMAN the eyes of the beardy stone face in the wall light up and one of the Vestal Virgins or whoever goes round putting little discs on everyone’s foreheads. Babs is a super light sleeper and sits up, knocking it off her brow, just as the most godawful epilepsy-inducing hullaballoo starts up. She clutches her head in agony as flashing lights and alarms start going off before passing out. Blimey.
You are a wild boar, a wild boar... |
The next morning, Susan, the Doctor, and Ian are up and breakfasting like Gods. The Doctor is really digging the glassware. Ian seems perturbed by Barbara’s super-long lie-in, and indeed either our Babs is having a very disturbed sleep or Jacqueline Hill just had to run to get to her position, because she’s breathing way too quickly for a horizontal person. Ian has a mystery sore spot on his forehead; so does the Doctor. Of course we know it’s from the mystery discs but I like to think that even for a split second Ian wondered whether he may have been branded for prostitution in the night.
Anyway, Susan’s dress has arrived and she wants to show Barbara. When our Babs wakes up, however it becomes immediately apparent that all is not well. And it’s so stupidly simply done I feel like applauding. Because now we get to see the room from Barbara’s point of view, and it’s shabby as all fuck. When the Doctor hands her a supposedly exquisite glass full of juice, all we see is ‘a dirty old mug’; she bats it away, and of course everyone thinks she’s a) crazy and b) rude. But then when we see Barbara from the others’ point of view, she’s still in her lovely dress and everything’s still fancy schmancy. Ian being Ian, he tries the old ‘shake the hysteric’ routine and gives Barbara an ineffectual jostling, but to no avail, proving once again how shit the Chesterton Method is.
Being routinely disbelieved is a bitter pill to take |
Susan shows Babs her new dress, which we see is indeed ‘dirty rags’, and Ian, who has certainly changed his tune since last night, tries to remind Barbara that the people here have given them everything. ‘They’ve given you nothing’, says Babs, bluntly.
Enter Altos, the Man in the High Tassles, wearing Miss Havisham’s curtains; he immediately knows Babs’s brainwashing has been a failure, and she knows he knows it. He wants to take her to see their physicians; Babs is having precisely none of it and scarpers; Ian wants to go after her (because of course) but Altos tells him he’ll deal with her fit of Lady Cray. Ian, did you learn nothing from the last serial? If you don’t believe what Barbara says, sooner or later everyone ends up believing her the hard way.
Budget Smugglers |
Anyway, we now get to see Shabby Babs in a Dress of Tatty Unloveliness, running off into a stone chamber. She hears footsteps and hides behind a pillar. Fortunately, and against all logic, Altos doesn’t find her; unfortunately, he’s locked the door behind him. Barbara, alone, her friends brainwashed, trapped in an alien dungeon, and wearing a fucking awful dress, sits down and has a little cry.
Meanwhile, Altos is going to check in with his bosses…WHO ARE STALK-EYED SNAIL BRAINS IN JARS! Boogly-eyed monsters for the win!
'MEOW' |
But seriously they do look like Gary from Spongebob.
Anyway, Altos tells the Snail Brains that one of the women ‘has resisted the power of the Mesmeron’. I repeat, THE MESMERON. Ye GODS. More concerningly still, the rest of Team Tardis is going to get the next stage of treatment after a trip to the Doctor’s new lab, at which point they will be COMPLETELY SUBJUGATED. What is it with this planet and Free Will? Oh and Altos needs to kill Barbara. Because she has seen the TRUTH and is beyond their control. Damn right she is. Also, YIKES. Oh and the woman who placed the discs on everyone’s heads? Her name is Sabetha, and she’s going to be punished for Babs’s sleeping habits. Poor Sabetha.
Back in the cell, Babs is dozing when she hears footsteps and hides oh-so-stealthily behind the pillar again. Sabetha has been thrown into the mix, and Babs recognises her as the girl who put the discs on their foreheads; how she knows this I am not prepared to say. Anyway, Sabetha is pretty zombified, and despite Barbara’s best efforts, all she manages to say is ‘I am to be punished’. Exasperation ensues.
Meanwhile, the Doctor and Ian are being reassured that Babs was suffering from Victorian Lady Disease and is now under sedation. Ian is, uncharacteristically, totally fine with this, and thinks they’ll maybe be able to visit her later. Because this is what the plot requires of him at the moment. The Doctor pays lip service to being concerned for Barbara’s welfare before essentially saying ‘hey ho nothing we can do right now let’s see my lab now please’.
Then there’s another triumph for Shoestring Budget Sci-Fi: upon entering the super-duper science lab, Ian and Doctor immediately start nerding out at a room that is totally empty but for a manky old mug on a bench. It’s like the Emperor’s New Clothes only without the moral bit. Ian is excited about something called a cyclotron, which is apparently an early form of particle accelerator; I bet he’d swoon with excitement if anyone ever showed him around CERN. The Doctor reckons that, with equipment like the manky old mug, he might be able to repair the Tardis’s time thingummy; oh, comedy.
Meanwhile, back in the cell, Sabetha is fondling something on a chain around her neck…IT’S A KEY OF MARINUS! Sabetha has a touch of the Gollums about her and claims it’s hers and was given to her by her masters as the thing she desired most; Babs puts two and two together and asks her if Arbitan is her father. Sabetha’s memory would appear to have been jogged. And indeed the Bechdel test would appear to have been passed this week. Thank goodness.
Elsewhere, the Snail Brains have plans for Team Tardis: Ian is to go into manual labour, the Doctor is to put his mind to ‘increasing manpowers’ (whatever that is), and Susan is to replace Sabetha being a hostess with the mostess and brainwasherwoman. Because alien Snail Brains are well into gender stereotyping.
Back in the cell, Babs is trying to get a very tired Sabetha to remember more things. Giving up on her variant of the Chesterton Method (arm-gripping and slowly articulating motivational stuff into the face of the grippee), she falls back on the Cuddle Method before scarpering behind the pillar again as Altos’s footsteps draw nearer. Altos grabs ragdoll Sabetha by the arm and tells her she’s to come with him; meanwhile, Babs has made a break for the door. Altos intercepts her and they have a brief scuffle, during which Babs is thrown to the ground, gets up, tries again, and is about to be throttled with a raggedy piece of Altos’s costume when Sabetha comes up from behind and smashes a stool over his head. GIRL POWER! Barbara tells Sabetha she has to go find the others and ‘try and convince them’ (of what?), and that she’ll come back for her if she’s successful; Sabetha goes to sleep.
Sabetha is smashing |
Out in the corridors, Babs is sneaking about; hearing a noise, she ducks behind a doorway before realising she’s run into Ian! Relieved, she runs over to hug him, telling him she thought they must have got to him; realising that he is not hugging her back and that there is therefore something terribly wrong with the Universe, she breaks off. And indeed Ian is now in full zombie mode and must take her to his leaders. Barbara is too busy trying to stop her dress falling down to resist much.
Oblivious as ever to Ms. Hill's wardrobe malfunctions |
As Barbara is bundled through the door, she comes face to face with the Snail Brain Bell Jars, and swiftly pronounces them ‘disgusting’. She tries to appeal to Ian, but the Snail Brains talk over her:
MORPHO: We are the masters of this place! Our brains outgrew our bodies, it is our intelligence that has created this whole city. But we need the help of the human body to feed us and to carry out our orders.Before we go on to the next bit, in which Bamfbara is a BAMF, let’s take a moment to appreciate the ongoing Marxist subtext of this serial, in which the Bourgeoisie are so grotesquely out of whack with the Proletariat that they are entirely divorced from the literal, physical ‘body’ of humanity and yet depend on them for their survival.
BARBARA: You use your people to act as machines for you.
MORPHO: Much more than machines. The human body is the most flexible instrument in the world, no mechanical device could reproduce its mobility and dexterity.
BARBARA: So, I'm to become one of your slaves?
MORPHO: No, you have seen the truth of our city, it is beyond our power to erase this from your memory. You must be destroyed. Kill her. Kill her.
ANYWAY, in yet another instance of a woman being nearly throttled to death by a man on a kids’ TV show, Ian the Serial Strangler gets his hands around Barbara’s throat. But then OH YES PLEASE, after a brief moment of panic in which she tries to get through to Ian by calling his name a lot, Barbara decides she has finally had enough of this victimisation bullshit; you can actually see the moment where she suddenly decides ‘ACTUALLY FUCK THIS’, at which point she flings Ian’s hands away and starts smashing shit up Russian Revolution style:
Barbara’s quadruple homicide seems to have done the trick: as the last Snail Brain’s eye stalk wilts pathetically, Ian snaps out of it. It is very much time for hugs.
Later on, through the Power of the Boatneck, Babs has found the outfit she was wearing before her Greco-Roman fashion disaster, and she and Ian have been reunited with the Doctor. It seems Barbara’s killing spree has awoken the citizens of Morphoton to the shitty reality of their living conditions and they’re burning the city in a full-on riot, which is what happens when you don’t have a provisional government in place ready to take over once you’ve toppled your tyrant(s) of choice. Everyone agrees they need to get the hell out of Dodge before the revolution catches up with them; Susan’s bringing Sabetha and Altos, as it seems the latter is also one of Arbitan’s crew.
It turns out Altos had a chum who went on ahead to find the fourth key in a city called Millenials Millenius, a super-advanced and well-ordered society. The Doctor, who clearly can’t be arsed to rough it in (as we shall discover) the jungle or an icy wasteland, decides he’s going to jump ahead and search for Altos’s pal and have some Doctor Time away from the humans and Susan, who’s going to stay with the main party. The Doctor’s self-interest continues to be hilariously blatant. They decide to meet up in five days, and Susan turns her travel dial after a ludicrously swift goodbye to her Grandfather. Ongoing issues are ongoing.
Then HOLY DYSTOPIA BATMAN Susan arrives in a jungle where everything is screaming, Catching Fire style. She claps her hand over her ears and screams for the screaming to stop; we clap our hands over our ears and do much the same thing.
GALLOPING CROSSOVERS, HAS SUSAN INADVERTENTLY FOUND HERSELF IN THE MIDDLE OF THE 75TH ANNUAL HUNGER GAMES? WHAT AWAITS OUT HEROES IN THE SCREAMING JUNGLE APART FROM SCREAMING? WILL WILLIAM HARTNELL NOW HAVE A LOVELY HOLIDAY AND RETURN REFRESHED? WILL BARBARA BE ALLOWED TO HAVE A FEW EPISODES IN WHICH SHE IS NOT THREATENED WITH BODILY HARM? WILL SUSAN GET SOMETHING BETTER TO DO THAN SCREAM? WILL IAN GET A CHANCE TO CHANGE HIS OUTFIT?
Summary (as applicable to this episode)
Does it pass the Bechdel test? Indeed it does! Hurrah for Sabetha!
Is the gaze problematic? Not especially.
Is/are the woman companion(s) dressed 'for the Dads'? No. Altos, on the other hand...
Does a woman fall over/twist her ankle (whilst running from peril)? No.
Does a woman wander off alone for the sole dramatic purpose of getting into trouble so she can be rescued later? No.
Is/are the woman companion(s) captured? Everyone gets brainwashed but Barbara, and though Barbara does end up in a cell it's an accidental imprisonment as she just happened to hide in a dungeon.
Does the Doctor/a man companion/any other man have to rescue the woman companion(s) from peril? HELL NO. It's Barbara's turn to save everyone's skins this week.
Is/are the woman companion's/s' first/only reaction(s) to peril gratuitous screaming? Susan a bit.
Does a woman companion go into hysterics over something reasonably minor? Susan a bit.
Does it pass the Bechdel test? Indeed it does! Hurrah for Sabetha!
Is the gaze problematic? Not especially.
Is/are the woman companion(s) dressed 'for the Dads'? No. Altos, on the other hand...
Does a woman fall over/twist her ankle (whilst running from peril)? No.
Does a woman wander off alone for the sole dramatic purpose of getting into trouble so she can be rescued later? No.
Is/are the woman companion(s) captured? Everyone gets brainwashed but Barbara, and though Barbara does end up in a cell it's an accidental imprisonment as she just happened to hide in a dungeon.
Does the Doctor/a man companion/any other man have to rescue the woman companion(s) from peril? HELL NO. It's Barbara's turn to save everyone's skins this week.
Is/are the woman companion's/s' first/only reaction(s) to peril gratuitous screaming? Susan a bit.
Does a woman companion go into hysterics over something reasonably minor? Susan a bit.
Is a woman 'spared' the ordeal of having to do/witness something unpleasant by a man who makes a decision on her behalf/keeps her deliberately ignorant? No.
Does a man automatically disbelieve or belittle something a woman (companion) says happened to her? As ever, nobody believes Barbara.
Does a man talk over a woman or talk about a woman as though she isn't there? Yes.
Does the woman companion have to be calmed/comforted by the Doctor/a man companion/a man? I'd say Ian needs a hug as much as Barbara does after all that business with the brains, so I'm going to say it's evens.
Is a woman the first/only person to be (most gratuitously) menaced by the episode's antagonist(s)? Yup. Barbara. Also she's already had to deal with attempted strangulation way too often. I disapprove.
Is a man shamed into doing/not doing something because the alternative is a woman doing/not doing something? No.
Does the woman companion come up with a plan? Yes.
Does the woman companion do something stupid/banal/weird which inspires a man to be a Man with a Plan? Nope.
Does a woman come up with a theory and is it ridiculed by the Doctor/a man? Yes and yes.
Does a woman call the Doctor out on his bullshit? Barbara calls out literally everyone this week.
Does a woman get to be a badass? BARBARA SMASH. SABETHA SMASH.
Is the young, strong, straight, white male lead the person most often in control of the situation? Nope. Makes a change!
Is there past/future/alien sexism? They seem to have pretty Victorian ideas about women and hysteria in Morphoton, but otherwise not so much.
Does a 'present'-day character call anybody out on past/future/alien sexism? No.
Did a woman write/direct/produce this episode? No/No/Yes.
Verdict
Hurrah for Barbara! This week is very much her episode, and though she mostly gets lucky with her 'better start smashing jars' tactic, it's still a very quick bit of thinking under pressure. I'm not happy with the amount of let's-put-the-women-under-immediate-threat-of-bodily-harm that's going on of late, but I do love that this is the week where Barbara has very much had enough of being victimised and doesn't let the fact that the person trying to kill her is her zombified friend get in the way of being a badass. Interesting that this is the first time she's ever actually killed anyone (having been of course complicit in the Dalek genocide a few episodes back) and that she doesn't seem to give it much thought because they're boogly-eyed snail brains rather than humanoids. It's also interesting that the Doctor seems to get his 'well the baddies are dead now so let's move on and leave the locals to clear up the mess' approach to things from the two humans, who don't seem to be particularly worried about the fact that one of them has just plunged an entire civilisation into revolutionary chaos. I always find the politics of Terry Nation stories fascinating and this is no exception. On with the screaming jungle! Or the jungle at any rate.